HeyJaredThe Creep Off
Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category.
- Indexed episodes, last 90 days
- 12
- Latest publication
- Sep 29, 2026
- Audience
- Checking…
- Earliest in this view
- Jul 6, 2026
Latest episodes
Episode 332: The One Where Vinnie loses his Shit (opens the original)
Read excerpt
Who Is the Creepiest Neighbor? Karl and Vinnie each bring a neighbor from hell, and you decide who deserves the point. Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam, the Scum Parade, and more people you’ll be glad don’t live next door. Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff. Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: Mother accused of giving away baby to stranger at bus stop School employee allegedly stabbed delivery driver with a pen 6 times because he was late Convicted
Episode 331: Lonely in St. Petersburg (opens the original)
Read excerpt
Karl & Vinnie welcome another competitor into the contest: Jerry Banfield, an expert in this week’s category... Creeps on Dating Apps. Jerry enters the competition with a chance to flip the guest score to 5 if he can take down Karl & Vinnie! Will he single-handedly force them to spin the dreaded Tandem Wheel of Consequences? Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam, the Scum Parade, and all the usual insensitive comedy you’ve come to expect! Become a Patron or a YouTube member for Friday’s Scum Stream and other bon
Episode 330: A Headless Flock of Seagulls (opens the original)
Read excerpt
Karl & Vinnie celebrate Grandparents Day by nominating grandparents who prove that getting older doesn’t mean getting kinder or wiser, turns out some of them are pretty shitty! Who is the Creepiest Grandparent? You decide! Become a Patron or a YouTube member for Friday’s Scum Stream and other bonus content. Vote for this week’s winner at Patreon.com/TheCreepOff Voicemail: 585-371-8108 Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: Where's Waldo? She Is Lying Naked Atop A Wooden Pallet | The Smo
Episode 329: Stop Mething Around (opens the original)
Read excerpt
Join Karl, Vinnie, and the unmistakable voice of Syracuse, Brian McBride, as they celebrate Labor Day the only way they know how, with a special Scum Parade! The guys are clocking in to cover some of societies biggest wastes of space! Plus, Karl’s Cop Cam, your voicemails, and more! Check out the stories here: Glamorous TV host weeps as she’s sentenced to death by hanging for involvement in drug trafficking gang She does that every morning': Brentwood residents say woman defecating on sidewalk i
Episode 328: Down to Clown (opens the original)
Read excerpt
WHOOP WHOOP! Karl & Vinnie are heading to the Dark Carnival to find out which Juggalo deserves the title of Biggest Creep! PLUS: Karl’s Cop Cam, The Scum Parade, your voicemails and more! Don’t forget to vote for who brought the biggest creep at patreon.com/thecreepoff. Check out this week’s scum parade stories here: 57326209 | Wayne County Sheriff's Office, NY Tulsa cops hunting 'serial defecator' who terrorized local businesses Fast food worker 'trying to serve own penis' to a female customer
Publishing over time
Last 90 days. Choose a month to open its work.
Recurring subjects
Named in the text we hold. One piece can cover several.
Not enough subject data for this period yet.
Audience
No verified audience measurement yet.
About this data
Counts cover the work we have indexed. Tone needs enough text and a confident classification. Excerpts and episode notes are not full articles or transcripts.
Identity or attribution wrong? Suggest a correction.